By the afternoon of 12 November 2026, Liz Harrison had collected her dog Pepper from MedVet in Worthington, Ohio. ABC6 reported that the person who bought Pepper on Facebook Marketplace had contacted Harrison to give the dog back. The same station had reported the theft a day earlier.
Pepper, a 9-year-old French bulldog, was taken around noon on 10 November from the family's car in the parking lot of J. Alexander's restaurant in Worthington. Harrison told ABC6 they were in the area for an appointment with Pepper's veterinary ophthalmologist and had gone inside to pick up food. When they came out, the rear window was smashed and Pepper was gone. She said Pepper needs medicine three times a day. The right eye was operated on in 2020 and had caused more trouble in the previous few weeks. Harrison has had Pepper since the dog was 16 weeks old. At home Pepper lives with Olive, the family's other French bulldog, who is 5.
ABC6 said Pepper was taken to MedVet for an evaluation and that the family picked her up there. The station did not report what the examination found, and it did not name the buyer. In the theft story, Harrison said she would rather the dog be left at a shelter or a veterinary office, and that she would collect Pepper with no questions asked. Columbus police were still investigating the break-in when the reunion story was published. The station had asked anyone with video from the restaurant parking lot to contact them.
The published record of the return is this one newsroom. Later write-ups repeat it. They are not a separate check on the buyer's account or on Pepper's health after the visit.